They Can’t Both Be Right, Can They?

This from Muhammad Shafiq in this morning’s D&C:

With Imam Mohammad, Islam in America took a new historic turn. Americans had equated mainstream Islam with that of Nation of Islam and that it was a religion of hate and rejection. To many it was the “devil” religion and very few could think of Islam as part of Abrahamic faith and a religion of peace, love and care.

And this from ex-Muslim Muhammad Kemel in today’s World Net Daily:

Sadly I heard some of our American leaders and church pastors state that Islam is a peaceful religion, and what happened on 9/11 was done by fanatic Muslims…These individuals ignore the fact that the main goal of Islam is to rule the world…the average peaceful Muslim and moderate western Muslim are that way because they have not studied the Quran…If a Muslim begins to study the Quran, understands the true religion of Islam, and what true Islam requires a true Muslim to do, he will either reject Islam or he will become a Muslim committed to violence.

They can’t both be right, can they?