The Catholic Spectator

  1. Seamless Garment Nonsense

    “This is the most prickly point,” said the Rev. Ronald J. Cioffi, director of the Office of Social Concerns for the Diocese of Trenton. “You may vote for a person who is pro-choice if you feel you have a moral reason to support the candidate for his stand on other issues.” From a story in The Times of Trenton, NJ.

    The seamless garment continues to wreak havoc. The Diocese of Trenton officially supports the idea of voting for baby killing enablers. I guarantee they would never issue a statement that says you could vote for a white supremacist candidate as long as he was solid on other issues.

    (Read more…)


  2. The Latest from St. Anne’s

    “My brother and his family have been long-time members of St. Anne’s – until just recently. The altar servers have been instructed that cassocks are strictly forbidden and there will be no more incense. The woman you are speaking about(Sister Sobala) also was seen wearing a t-shirt with an image of the nativity scene with one major alteration – the words ‘Its a girl!’ and the Crucifix she wears is different as well – the Corpus is not Christ, but clearly a woman. She also shared in a meeting that she has been waiting since the 1970s for the Church to ordain women and she thinks the time is finally upon us. A letter is on the way to the Papal Nuncio’s office if it has not yet arrived and attached are several signatures of eye-witnesses to this nonsense.” From Rich Leonardi’s Ten Reasons


  3. Curran Just a Big Bully

    “The Cardinal explains that dissident theologians, led by Charles Curran and other dissident clergy, attempted to bully their fellow priests into signing on to documents of formal dissent. He relates at length his own experiences of being bullied, on August 4, 1968, when a meeting of Baltimore priests was convened, with the intention of pressing them into signing the Washington ‘Statement of Dissent.’ “

    “That abusive pressure on priests loyal to Rome and the fractionization of unity resulting from large numbers of openly dissenting clergy has remained problematic to this day. ‘Abusive, coercive dissent has become a reality in the Church and subjects her to violent, debilitating, unproductive, chronic controversies,’ writes Cardinal Stafford. ‘Diocesan presbyterates have not recovered from the July/August nights in 1968.’ ” Read the full story on Lifesite News.


  4. Father Joan?

    When asked about wanting to become a priest, she(Sister Joan Sobala) announced quite boldly, “It is no secret that since 1975, I have wanted to become a priest.” When asked by a parishioner if she understood that this was against the acceptance of the Catholic Church, she told the parishioner that he was “out of line”. Excerpted from Rich Leonard’s Ten Reasons.


  5. Where Have All the Soldiers Gone?

    The following piece was written by Tucker Wilson, Co-Director of the Focus Pregnancy Help Center. His plea should not go unheeded. EM

    Where Have All The Soldiers Gone?

    Why are there so many more women picketing and counseling and praying outside abortion clinics than men? Are we too busy working; or performing other charities; or sticking another 6-pack behind our belts; or watching another meaningless sports event? Or is it that we don’t think about it?

    (Read more…)


  6. Bishop Doesn’t Mince Words

    “Indeed, a nation that condemns to abortion our beautiful and blameless unborn babies betrays itself as morally, ethically and politically untrustworthy and disinclined to give due care and attention to the poorest and weakest members of our society.” Bishop Joseph Devine quoted in today’s Lifesite News.


  7. Confounding the Liberals

    “The Holy Father has requested that those whom he gives communion to will kneel, and his preference is that they receive communion on the tongue,” said Father Mark Podesta, an official World Youth Day spokesman. From the July 19 issue of The Australian.

    Pope Benedict confounds the liberals once again. Perhaps its time to bring back the altar rails to our desecrated churches. In the spirit of pre-Vatican II!


  8. The DOR’s Favorite Dissident

    “Father Charles Curran will lecture and answer questions on Catholic Social Teaching at the Church of the Transfiguration, 50 West Bloomfield Rd, Pittsford on Saturday, July 26, 2008 at
    10:00 a.m. in the Church. You are warmly invited to join us Saturday, July 26th at 10:00 am to hear and meet Father Curran.” From the July 6 bulletin of St. John of Rochester.

    “Father Curran is a Catholic priest who has long been at odds with several of the Church’s fundamental moral teachings. Because of his aggressive and vocal condemnation of the Church’s teachings on matters such as abortion, contraception, and homosexuality, Curran was investigated by the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith in the late 1970’s and early 1980’s. In 1986, at the recommendation of then-Cardinal Ratzinger, Pope John Paul II officially forbad Curran from teaching at any Catholic school and stripped him of the title of ‘Catholic theologian’.” From a Lifesite news story in October of 2007.

    Curiously, Charles Curran’s engagement here has not yet been published in the bulletin of the host parish, Transfiguration.

    As many of you surely know, Charles Curran is a notorious dissident. His errors are especially egregious in the area of the Church’s social teaching. In fact, as recently as October of 2007 Bishop Gregory Aymond of Austin, Texas instructed his priests not to publicize an appearance in his diocese by Charles Curran. He cited Curran’s notoriety as a “dissident theologian”. This is what the bishop had to say:

    “In his letter to his priests, Austin Bishop Aymond expressed his disappointment that a Catholic university would give a platform to such a dissident voice. He said, ‘I realize that he is still a priest in good standing, but he is not a theologian. Therefore, I believe that it does not foster the Catholic identity of a university to present him as a guest lecturer’.”


  9. Our Shepherds are MIA

    ” ‘Can anyone out there score me some consecrated communion wafers?’ Myers continued by saying, ‘if any of you would be willing to do what it takes to get me some, or even one, and mail it to me, I’ll show you sacrilege, gladly, and with much fanfare.’ ” UMM professor Paul Zachary Myers quoted in a press release by the Catholic League.

    This nutty professor is soliciting Eucharistic Hosts on the internet in order to desecrate them. Bill Donohue’s Catholic League has rightly publicized and responded to this outrage.

    Why is it always a layperson who is out there responding to these types of outrages that are occurring more and more frequently in our country? Isn’t that what bishops are supposed to be doing? Can’t the multi-million dollar operation at the USCCB find some time to defend our Faith against these outrageous assaults on the Church and our formerly Christian culture?

    In Canada, Christianity is under full fledged assault for so-called “hate crimes”. Christian pastors and Catholic priests are being hauled in front of human rights commissions by homosexual activists and others for teaching and communicating the truths of Christianity. One priest in particular has been forced to spend $20,000 of his own money to defend himself in this kangaroo court system. How long will it be before we in the U.S. are faced with this same oppression? Unfortunately it isn’t too far off if we end up with a President Obama and a Democratic Congress in November.

    If elements of Christian doctrine become designated as hateful in the U.S. can we count on our shepherds to stand up and be counted or will it be left to the laity to once again defend Christ and His Church? I’m afraid we already know the answer. After all, speaking out forcefully might jeopardize the government hush money that goes to funding Catholic Charities and other diocesan initiatives. This government subsidy has already been quite effective at muting many of our shepherds voices on the issue of baby killing. That is, they are mute unless the issue can be rolled into the seamless garment along with climate change, immigration, racism, etc.

    Father Corapi recently wrote that weak leadership in the Church is a punishment for sin. He also said that the Church is filled with too many CEOs and very few apostles. I wish he was wrong but he speaks the truth. If only our bishops would listen.


  10. We Can’t Agree on Everything

    “Misconceptions about Islam abound in the United States. So Muslims may find it helpful to remind fellow Americans that Islam is an Abrahamic, monotheistic religion that has many similarities in virtues and values to Christianity and Judaism.” Muhammad Shafiq in this morning’s D&C.

    “A plan is being discussed by lawmakers in Iran that would require the death penalty for anyone who leaves Islam for Christianity or someone who promotes such a conversion even on the Internet, according to a new report from Compass Direct News.” From an article in this morning’s WND.

    The death penalty for conversion is one area where Christianity does not share similar virtues and values with Islam. Thank goodness.


  11. The Rest of the Story

    Rich Leonardi has posted an interesting flyer regarding the recent closing of Holy Family Church. The flyer contains “the rest of the story” that you won’t likely see reported in the local D&C. Thank goodness we have the internet.


  12. DOR Shuttering Rocks the Faithful

    “Parents and staff filled the bleachers. Many sobbed. So did the kids — particularly the sixth-graders, whom Fortunato said seem to be taking it the worst. Some students have been wrestling with their faith, blaming their school closing on God. Staff have told the kids this isn’t God’s doing; It’s humans’, Fortunato said.” Excerpted from an article about the final day at the Catherine McAuley School in Greece.


  13. Another Local Conversion Story

    By Lisa Spellman

    Out of all the gifts we receive from God in our lives, perhaps one of the most uniquely human is free will. While He grants us the ability to make our own decisions, it is through accepting responsibility for our choices that God teaches us and, often, reaches us. God does not force. And while he allows us our individual freedom, it is through His grace that He manifests His greatness and love.

    The awesomeness God’s grace and guidance have had a special significance for Dorothy Hayes. As an independent-minded woman, she is not one to be pressed into making decisions. A Catholic convert of 20 years, Dorothy describes her Catholicism as the “greatest gift of my life”. In her story, there are no dramatic revelations that influenced her decision to convert and no discrete turning points. There are only His gentle reminders throughout her life, almost as if God was saying, “I’m here. I’m here.” She speaks of the breadth and depth of God’s workings in her life, and over time how she grew more aware of His near presence. To this day, Dorothy has a great appreciation of how perfectly He understands each one of us: “He knows us so well, He knows just how to approach us.”

    (Read more…)