The Catholic Spectator

  1. Everything Is Just Hunky Dory

    “The Catholic population in the 12-county Rochester Diocese fell from 362,000 in 1965 to 339,000 in 2007 (about 60 percent of those Catholics are in Monroe County), according to the diocese. In 1995, 162 parishes existed; today there are 139. Sunday Mass attendance has fallen from an average of 107,489 in 2001 to 84,087 last year.” From yesterday’s Democrat and Chronicle.

    As a favorite priest of mine said yesterday (about this piece): “Everything is just hunky dory! It’s as if we’re living in a nut house!” I couldn’t have said it better myself.


  2. Priestess To Offer The Sacraments

    “The Community of St. Joseph’s House of Hospitality, the Rochester Catholic Worker, calls Chava (Michelle) Redonnett to be their priest, to serve the community by offering the sacraments, and nurturing and building the community that serves our guests.” From the November 19, 2007 newsletter of St. Joseph’s House of Hospitality.

    Chava Redonnet is in the process of formation to be “ordained” a priestess. She will be serving as chaplain of St. Joseph’s House on South Ave. Because St. Joseph’s identifies itself as Catholic it would be wise for Catholic donors to be wary of supporting this particular group.

    Although the organization apparently does good work in supporting the material needs of their clients, they will surely be spiritually confused by a woman posing as a priest in a self identified Catholic organization. This woman cannot “offer the sacraments” in any Catholic sense.

    It is a shame that the clients of St. Joseph’s House will be deprived of the Sanctifying grace of the authentic sacraments that can only be imparted by a validly ordained male priest. Just another example of the state of confusion that prevails throughout our diocese.


  3. New Students Need Not Apply

    Registration for families who are new to diocesan schools began on Tuesday, but diocesan spokesman Doug Mandelaro said that marketing to new families would raise false hopes.

    ‘There just aren’t a lot of seats available,’ he said.

    Holy Cross parent Karen Cavacos questioned why the diocese would lower tuition to attract new children when there would be no room for them.”

    Good question Karen. Unless the plan is to continue the progression towards the elimination of the Catholic school system in the DOR.


  4. NOW’s Anti-Catholic Bigotry

    Jon Powers, an Iraq war veteran from Clarence, Erie County, and a Democratic candidate in the 26th District, was accused of not being committed to the pro-choice cause and being opposed to same-sex marriage, based on an honor bestowed on him by a Catholic organization.

    Powers’ honor by the Hibernians is ‘a serious problem’ for the candidate, said Linda Stephens, political action committee chairwoman for Rochester NOW, a chapter of the National Organization for Women.”

    Sounds like a clear cut case of religious discrimination to me. Anyone from the DOR care to step up and defend this man and our Catholic faith against these bigots?


  5. School Closing Update

    After the DOR refused to modify its draconian school closing program many parents decided to fight on by ensuring a high re-enrolment rate in the remaining schools. Some of the re-enrollment rates being reported are 80% and higher. Christ the King school in Irondequoit hit full enrollment almost immediately and had to begin turning students away. This is believed to be the situation at several other of the remaining schools.

    The DOR plan was structured in the hopes that only about 48% of the displaced students would re-enroll. It appears that they may have grossly miscalculated. If indeed many students are being turned away will they reconsider and modify their plan?

    Of course the DOR may never admit that they are turning students away. It may be up to the parents of displaced students to contact the news media to let them know the real story. It remains to be seen whether or not the media will do its job and report the truth of the situation. We’ll be watching.


  6. Show Me the Money

    The following is a partial transcript of a conversation between a Planned Parented representative in Idaho and a pro-life advocate posing as a donor. The donor is telling the PP representative that his son is having trouble getting into college because of affirmative action policies that are putting his Caucasian son at a disadvantage. The donor wants to make sure his money will go specifically to abort the babies of black women.

    Although this conversation does not officially represent Planned Parenthood’s position on killing black babies, it is an ugly reminder of the eugenicist roots of the organization and its founder, Margaret Sanger.

    PP Donor: “Yeah, he’s (donor’s son) trying to get into colleges…he’s really faced troubles with affirmative action.

    PP Rep: “Mmhmm”

    Donor: “…the less black kids out there the better”

    Rep: “Ha, ha. Understandable, understandable.”

    Donor: “I wanna protect my son so that he can go to college.”

    Rep: “Alright. Excuse my hesitation. This is the first time I’ve had a donor call and make this kind of request, so I’m excited and don’t want to leave anything out.”

    Go to the LA Advocate for more information on their investigation into Planned Parenthood’s willingness to accept donations for the specific purpose of killing black babies.


  7. Jesus Was A Poor Black Man

    “Jesus was a poor black man who lived in a country and who lived in a culture that was controlled by rich white people.” Obama’s preacher buddy, Jeramiah Wright.


  8. Orthodoxy Is The Solution

    Although Mass attendance in the DOR is in a state of free fall, one parish has managed to buck the trend. Our Lady of Victory, a parish that is a bastion of orthodoxy, has seen a tremendous increase in registered parishioners in recent years. This in a parish that is located in a less than desirable urban area in downtown Rochester. Many of the parishioners are suburban refugees who have been displaced from their home parishes by liberal looniness.

    Our Lady of Victory is characterized by reverent liturgies, outstanding musical accompaniment, no nonsense homilies, and a priest/administrator who is orthodox to the bone. There is no Sister Susie giving the homily, no altar girls driving out the altar boys, and no politically correct homilies. People are allowed to worship in peace and don’t leave Mass frustrated by the latest liturgical abuse.

    If the diocese really wants to turn things around here, then they will find that the solution is right under their nose. It’s in a tiny little church in the heart of Rochester.

    Liberalism equals decline, orthodoxy equals growth. It doesn’t get much simpler than that.


  9. Why Not Cohabitate?

    Why is it that so many homosexuals are clamoring for the right to be legally married when so many heterosexuals are abandoning marriage in favor of cohabitation? Cohabitation, especially among the younger generation, has become a way of life for many in our society. It has become socially acceptable not only to live together but also to foster children out of these relationships.

    In the United States about one in three children is now born out of wedlock. The day may be coming when it will be considered counter cultural for couples to be joined together in marriage.

    In Canada, where homosexual unions are now legally recognized, there have been relatively few homosexuals stepping forward to formalize their relationships. This certainly lends credence to the argument that this movement for legal recognition is nothing more than a cover for cultural legitamcy.

    It is certainly true that some homosexuals want access to the financial benefits that are acquired through “marriage”. However, by and large, this movement has been a vehicle for cultural acceptance of a lifestyle that many still consider to be deviant and characterized by promiscuity.

    A recent study in the Netherlands confirms the legitimacy of this position. The study found that even in supposedly stable relationships, homosexuals had an average of eight partners a year outside of their “monogamous” relationships. The rate of new HIV infections was the highest among those who were professed to be living monogomausly.

    The concepts of monogamy and commitment apparently have different meanings in the homosexual world. We would do well to remember this the next time we hear activists or politicians clamoring for the right to homosexual “marriage”.


  10. Dramatic Decline

    I just picked up an interesting statistic on Mass attendance from the DOR Catholic Blog. Weekend Mass attendance for the DOR has declined 22% between the years 2000 and 2007. This represents a numerical drop from 108,000 attendees to 84,000 attendees. During that same time period, according to the census bureau, the population in the 12 county DOR geographical area has actually seen a slight increase. This fact discredits any theory of declining Mass attendance mirroring a decline in area population.

    If the diocese was in a state of good health, we would actually have seen a slight increase in weekend Mass attendance throughout the DOR’s 12 county region over the last several years. The diocese is not in a state of good health.

    If this current rate of catastrophic decline continues, then we will be down to about 50,000 Mass attendees in less than 10 years. This in an area that has a population of well over one million people. This decline roughly parallels the decline in priestly vocations for the diocese.


  11. Pope Benedict Takes charge

    Pope Benedict is slowly but surely making changes in the Church that will bear fruit for many years to come. Some of the more significant changes are as follows (as summarized by the January 31 issue of The Remnant newspaper):

    The Motu Propio. This document has not only liberated the Mass of all time it is also prompting a reexamination of the Novus Ordo. This reexamination will certainly lead to a more reverent and sensible Novus Ordo Mass. One day the Traditional Mass will again predominate or the Novus Ordo will be changed so dramatically as to be very close in ritual to the Latin Mass.

    The replacement of Piero Marini as the master of ceremonies at the Vatican. This means no more inculturated or rock concert liturgies for the Pope.

    Reinstating the traditional 2/3 vote requirement for papal conclaves.

    The coming of new and stricter rules for beatification and canoniization. Pope John Paul II averaged almost 20 canonizations per year during his reign. Pope Benedict is so far averaging only about 5 per year.

    The Pope’s recent admonishment of the Jesuit order.

    The Pope’s wearing of the traditional miter and the return of the papal throne.

    The Pope’s recent celebration of the Mass “facing God” in the Sistine Chapel.

    No more references to Vatican II as “the new springtime”, “new Pentecost”, “renewal”, etc.

    A thaw in relations with the Orthodox Church that appears to be a direct result of the Motu Propio.

    Calling for a worldwide revival of Eucharistic adoration in order to combat the crisis in vocations to the priesthood.

    The Pope’s directive to correct the mistranslation of “pro multis” in the consecration formula of the Novus Ordo from “for all” to “for many”. This translation has been fought over for years as “for all” implies a sort of universal salvation. “For many” is the traditional formula that acknowledges a particular orientation to Christ and the reality that not all will be saved.


  12. Wakeup And Smell The Coffee

    “More than one in four U.S. teen girls is infected with at least one sexually transmitted disease, and the rate is highest among blacks, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said on Tuesday. An estimated 3.2 million U.S. girls ages 14 and 19 — about 26 percent of that age group — have a sexually transmitted infection such as the human papillomavirus or HPV, chlamydia, genital herpes or trichomoniasis, the CDC said.” March 11 Reuters news article.

    It can be safely assumed that Catholic teenage girls were included in this survey. Perhaps it would be good for them to occasionally hear about the moral and physical dangers of premarital sex. This is a topic that might actually get their attention at a Sunday homily. They might even get the idea that there is more to being Catholic than worrying about global warming. They might even decide that it’s more important to save their souls rather than save the planet. This would be a good thing.


  13. Good News for Babies

    The downfall of Eliot Spitzer is being portrayed by many as a tragedy. However, the real tragedy occurred on day he was elected governor of New York State. There has never been a more rabid baby killing proponent as governor in the history of New York. In fact, he may be one of the most radical pro-abort governors in the history of the United States of America. His extremist RHAPP legislation was a dire threat to the lives of thousands of preborn babies of future generations. Therefore, his demise is not a tragedy but a triumph for those countless children who would have been killed had RHAPP become a reality.

    How ironic that another darling of NOW and NARAL will go down in history as an adulterer and abuser of women. The betrayal of his wife and the victimization of prostitutes are certainly not qualities that are readily associated with champions of women’s rights. May Spitzer’s demise be quickly followed by the demise of his culture of death RHAPP legislation.


  14. City Residents Need Not Apply

    ” ‘The church closings(Holy Rosary and Most Precious Blood) are part of a national trend of Catholics moving from the cities to the suburbs, resulting in declining attendance at city churches’, said Doug Mandelaro, spokesman for the Roman Catholic Diocese of Rochester.” From this morning’s D&C.

    “Go, therefore, and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you.” Matthew 28, 19-20.

    I don’t recall Jesus telling His disciples not to evangelize and baptize in urban areas. Does the diocese have a special rule that says that Catholicism is only for suburban people? And if all the Catholics have moved to the suburbs then why are so many suburban parishes clustering? Is the Catholic population in Rochester now relocating to rural areas?

    If current trends continue, then the diocese will cease to exist in about 50 years. Thankfully, current trends will not continue.


  15. DOR Near the Bottom

    The 20 dioceses with the lowest ratio of diocesan seminarians to Catholics in 2006-starting with the bottom-ranked diocese-were San Diego, Honolulu, Metuchen, Las Vegas, Laredo, Los Angeles, New York, Hartford, El Paso, Rochester, Santa Rosa, San Antonio, Galveston-Houston, Rockville Centre, Boston, Syracuse, Detroit, San Bernardino, Reno, and Monterey.” Catholic World Report, December, 2007.